354 – What the dying can teach us about living well: lessons on life and reflections on mortality

In this podcast episode with BJ Miller and Bridget Sumser, a foundational idea emerges early: death is not an external invader or a sudden, alien event but an intrinsic part of life itself. Living beings, by their very nature, die. This perspective challenges the common cultural narrative that death is something foreign that abruptly interrupts life. Instead, death is a process that begins the moment we are born, and it unfolds gradually, often over months or years, especially in the context of chronic illness.

This understanding reframes how we approach dying and living. Rather than seeing death as a failure or an enemy, it is a natural culmination of life’s journey. Recognizing this can help individuals and families prepare emotionally and practically for the end of life, fostering acceptance and reducing fear. It also highlights the importance of integrating the concepts of living, dying, and quality of life into a holistic view rather than treating them as separate or opposing experiences.

The Physiology and Experience of Dying

Miller and Sumser delve into the physiological realities of dying, particularly in the context of chronic illnesses like cancer, heart disease, and neurodegenerative conditions. The body shuts down progressively, often organ by organ, and this process can be unpredictable. Common signs include decreased appetite and fluid intake, increased fatigue, changes in mental status such as delirium, and altered breathing patterns. These changes are signals that the body is preparing for the end, and they should be respected rather than aggressively countered.

Delirium, a common feature in the final days, is especially important to understand. It can manifest as confusion, disorientation, or altered consciousness, and it profoundly affects how patients communicate and interact. Loved ones may misinterpret delirium-induced behaviors or words, leading to unnecessary distress. Recognizing delirium as a medical phenomenon rather than a reflection of the person’s true feelings can help families navigate these moments with greater compassion and less fear.

Palliative Care Versus Hospice: Clarifying the Continuum

A significant portion of the discussion focuses on distinguishing palliative care from hospice care, two terms often conflated but fundamentally different. Palliative care is a broad medical specialty aimed at improving quality of life for anyone with a serious illness, regardless of prognosis or treatment goals. It can be provided alongside curative treatments and addresses physical symptoms, psychological needs, and social support.

Hospice care, by contrast, is a subset of palliative care reserved for those nearing the end of life, typically with a prognosis of six months or less. It requires patients to forgo curative treatments and focuses exclusively on comfort and support during the final phase. The conversation highlights that hospice care is often initiated too late, with many patients only entering hospice in the last few weeks of life, missing opportunities for earlier comfort and support.

The Realities and Challenges of Home Hospice Care

The guests shed light on the practical realities of hospice care, especially when delivered at home. While many people express a desire to die at home, the support available through home hospice often falls short of what is needed for full-time care. Hospice teams provide expert support and visits but do not typically cover 24-hour caregiving or personal care tasks, which places a heavy burden on family members and friends.

This gap in caregiving resources can lead to situations where patients are readmitted to hospitals or nursing facilities because families are overwhelmed or unable to provide the necessary care. The lack of financial reimbursement for caregiving and residential hospice facilities further complicates the issue, making it difficult for many to realize their wish to die comfortably at home. This systemic challenge underscores the need for broader social and healthcare reforms to better support end-of-life care.

Cultural Attitudes Toward Death and Dying

The podcast explores how cultural factors shape our relationship with death. In many Western societies, death is often hidden, medicalized, and treated as a failure, which contributes to denial and avoidance. This cultural discomfort delays conversations about dying and advance care planning, resulting in rushed decisions and unnecessary suffering near the end of life.

Comparisons with other cultures, such as Japan and Scandinavian countries, reveal different approaches where aging and dying are more integrated into social life and cultural practices. These societies often have stronger social safety nets and more acceptance of death as a natural transition, which can ease the dying process. The discussion suggests that embracing death more openly and culturally normalizing conversations about mortality could improve the quality of dying and living.

The Role of Advanced Directives and Medical Decision-Making

Advanced directives emerge as a crucial tool for empowering patients and families in end-of-life care. These legal documents allow individuals to specify their wishes regarding medical treatments and designate a healthcare proxy to make decisions if they become incapacitated. Despite their importance, many people delay completing advanced directives, often due to discomfort with confronting mortality or misunderstanding their purpose.

Miller and Sumser emphasize that advanced care planning is not a one-time event but an ongoing conversation that evolves as a person’s health and perspectives change. The proxy decision-maker plays a vital role and must be well-informed about the patient’s values and preferences to advocate effectively. Early and honest discussions about goals of care can prevent unwanted interventions and ensure that treatment aligns with the patient’s wishes.

The Psychological and Relational Dimensions of Serious Illness

Beyond physical symptoms, the psychological and relational aspects of serious illness and dying are central themes. Patients often grapple with fear, grief, identity loss, and existential questions. The presence of a palliative care team can provide a safe space for patients to express these emotions, explore their fears, and find meaning amid uncertainty.

The relational unit of care extends beyond the patient to include family members and caregivers, whose experiences and needs are deeply intertwined with the patient’s journey. Supporting families emotionally and practically is essential, yet healthcare systems often lack the resources or structures to do this adequately. The conversation highlights the importance of holistic care that addresses the full spectrum of human experience during serious illness.

Lessons from the Dying: Regret, Forgiveness, and Acceptance

One of the most profound insights shared is the nature of regrets expressed by people nearing the end of life. Common regrets often revolve around not living authentically, suppressing emotions, or allowing shame and fear to create distance from oneself and others. The guests note that many people struggle most with forgiving themselves rather than seeking forgiveness from others.

This realization points to the importance of cultivating self-compassion and honesty throughout life, not just at the end. Accepting fear and regret as natural parts of the human experience can reduce suffering and foster a richer, more connected life. The dying teach us that embracing vulnerability and authenticity is key to living well and dying peacefully.

The Final Days: What Active Dying Looks Like

The podcast provides a detailed description of the active dying phase, typically the last 24 to 48 hours of life. During this time, the body undergoes significant physiological changes: kidney function declines, breathing patterns alter with periods of apnea and the characteristic “death rattle,” skin changes occur due to poor circulation, and consciousness often fades.

Understanding these signs can help families and caregivers prepare emotionally and practically. Importantly, the guests stress that the dying person may need moments of solitude to “let go,” and loved ones should feel permitted to take breaks without guilt. This phase is as much about the experience of those around the dying person as it is about the individual, emphasizing the need for compassion and presence.

The Power of Connection in the Face of Death

Connection emerges as a vital theme in the dying process. Whether it is connection to oneself, to loved ones, to nature, or even to strangers, maintaining relational ties can provide comfort and meaning. The guests note that even in altered states of consciousness or delirium, moments of connection can occur and be deeply significant.

This broad view of connection includes non-human elements such as pets or the environment, underscoring the expansive nature of human experience. Cultivating connection throughout life and especially near the end can alleviate feelings of isolation and foster a sense of belonging and peace.

The Emerging Role of Psychedelic-Assisted Therapy

The conversation touches on the promising research and anecdotal evidence surrounding psychedelic-assisted therapy, particularly with substances like psilocybin, in alleviating existential distress in terminally ill patients. These therapies can facilitate profound shifts in perception, helping patients move beyond fear and suffering to experience a sense of unity, acceptance, and peace.

While regulatory and clinical challenges remain, the guests acknowledge the potential of these treatments to complement traditional palliative care approaches. Psychedelic experiences can open new pathways to healing by bypassing cognitive barriers and fostering embodied, felt understanding, which may be transformative for those facing mortality.

Integrating Lessons on Mortality into Daily Living

Finally, Miller and Sumser reflect on how their experiences with dying patients have shaped their own lives. They emphasize the importance of embracing mortality as a constant companion rather than a distant threat. This awareness encourages living with greater presence, authenticity, and connection.

They caution against striving for a death free of fear or regret, instead advocating for a changed relationship with these emotions—accepting them as natural and manageable. The wisdom gained from the dying invites all of us to cultivate honesty, connection, and courage in our daily lives, ultimately enriching both our living and dying.

Videos

Full episode

Episode summary